Journeys & New BeginningsHome & LandFaith & ConvictionLegacy & Inheritance

A Name Between Two Rivers

In the document that made Stukely Westcott one of Providence’s original proprietors, the rivers come before his name.

The Wanasquatucket and the Moshassuck appear first, together with their grounds and meadows. Then come the terms of the arrangement, the money received, and the people who would share in it. Among the twelve associates named by Roger Williams, Stukely stands at the beginning of the list. Spellings changed as clerks and later historians carried his name forward. His place in the transaction is less uncertain: he was one of the men admitted to shared rights in the Providence lands.

For a descendant, that is the kind of discovery that can bring a long genealogy suddenly into focus. Generations of births and marriages lead backward to a name in an early document, beside rivers that can still be found on a map. The temptation is to stop there, with the satisfaction of belonging to the beginning.

But the document itself points farther back.

Before Williams could distribute rights among his associates, he had made an arrangement with the Narragansett leaders Canonicus and Miantonomo. Their agreement was formalized in a deed dated March 24, 1638. The National Park Service identifies their marks as a bow and an arrow. The men behind those marks had reasons of their own for receiving Williams. Trade could become more convenient. An English neighbor could also be an ally. Their country was already a place of government, negotiation and competing interests when the newcomers arrived.

Williams had needed somewhere to go. After his departure from Massachusetts, he had received assistance from the Wampanoag, only to find that the place where he first settled lay within Plymouth’s jurisdiction. His move into Narragansett territory was another attempt to establish a home beyond the authorities who would not accommodate him.

Stukely’s own journey brought him from Salem to Providence in 1638. The family’s preserved account places him among the early members of the Baptist congregation associated with Williams. In this small settlement, arrangements for belief and arrangements for land developed among many of the same people. A household needed a place to live; a religious dissenter needed somewhere he could remain.

The grant to Williams’s associates, conventionally dated October 8, 1638, carried the language of fellowship into the business of ownership. It gave the named men equal rights with Williams in enjoying and disposing of the lands, and provided for others whom the group might admit. Stukely’s interest became something he could pass onward. The Westcott descendants’ society records that in 1656 he gave his share of certain Pawtuxet meadows to his eldest son, Robert. Land acquired through one generation’s negotiations was becoming the next generation’s inheritance.

That inheritance is one reason the distinction between the documents matters. Stukely is named in Williams’s grant to his associates. The evidence considered here does not establish that he signed the earlier Narragansett deed. Family memory has preserved his connection to Providence’s founding, but compressed the steps by which he acquired his place in it.

The family connections continued beyond the names in the grant. Published genealogies identify Stukely’s grandson Jeremiah Westcott Jr. as the husband of Mary Warner, a granddaughter of Samuel Gorton, the religious dissenter who helped establish Warwick. The two men’s descendants joined the Westcott and Gorton families in a line preserved in the society’s later research.

Restoring those steps brings other people back into the story. Williams stands between the Narragansett agreement and the grant to his neighbors. Canonicus and Miantonomo stand behind the rights Williams claimed he could convey. Robert appears later, receiving his father’s share.

Stukely’s name remains there, where a descendant would hope to find it. Reading the whole transaction means following it in both directions: forward into the family, and backward to the people whose agreement made the settlement possible.

Behind the Story

This literary nonfiction account uses published historical and genealogical sources. The Gorton descent runs through Ann Gorton and Mary Warner, wife of Jeremiah Westcott Jr. Original records underlying the compiled lineage remain to be inspected. Sources vary between Mary Warner, Mary Gorton Warner and the family database’s Mary Ann Warner; uncertain dates are omitted. Stukely is a named grantee in Williams’s conveyance, not an established signatory of the original Narragansett deed. The grant survives through later copies and confirmations.

National Park Service: The Narragansett — https://home.nps.gov/rowi/learn/historyculture/narragansett.htm

Memoir of Roger Williams: reproduced deed — https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/63358/pg63358-images.html

Westcott Society: Stukeley Westcote, part 2 — https://sswda.org/Old-sswda-org/old/Archives/People/Bios/WestcoteStukeley_Incidents2.htm

Whitman: Westcott genealogy, printed p. 155 — https://www.seekingmyroots.com/members/files/G006977.pdf

Westcott Society: Betty Acker’s Devere Wescott lineage — https://sswda.org/Old-sswda-org/old/Archives/Items/calendar.htm

Gorton family compilation: Ann and Mary Warner — https://www.gottschfamily.net/Gorton/5.html