In 1809, a schoolmaster in East Fallowfield Township met a pupil he was afraid he couldn't whip. This was a serious professional difficulty for James McEntire, who believed that a teacher must be able to master the children placed in his charge. His prospective student, Jerry Gelvin, was described by the later township historian as a young giant. Jerry's education had been neglected, and he wanted to learn arithmetic. McEntire wished to teach the subject, but not, apparently, at the cost of accepting a man whom he could not physically subdue.
The classroom itself was an exercise in practical compromise. McEntire kept school in his weaving shop, with his son John working a loom at one end while pupils received their lessons at the other. To improve the light, a log had been removed from the wall and greased paper put in its place. There were no purpose-built school windows to look through, no separate building to keep the making of cloth distinct from the teaching of numbers. Work made room for education, and education learned to tolerate the work. Such arrangements belonged to a settlement still building its institutions from whatever materials and labor were available.
McEntire knew a good deal about making do. The county history says that he had come from Ireland after a shipwreck in which much of his family's property was lost. In 1802 he became determined to secure a tract in Fallowfield, but instead of immediately bringing his whole household, he put two young children into a little cabin on the land. Every Monday he left them provisions for the week; on Saturdays he returned for them. The historian remembered visitors asking for food and provisions sometimes giving out before the week was over. Once the children made a poor meal of wild onions and small potatoes taken from a growing patch. It is an episode difficult to reconcile with modern ideas of childhood, but it belongs to the same man who, a few years later, would teach children in the weaving shop.
The schoolmaster had survived a difficult migration, established himself on the land, and become known as a capable teacher. None of that prevented him from worrying about the size of Jerry Gelvin. In the society described by the historian, corporal punishment was commonly accepted as an instrument of school discipline. A teacher unable to administer it might imagine himself without effective authority, no matter how willing the student was to learn. Jerry's request exposed the absurdity in the assumption. He was large enough that the teacher feared being unable to compel obedience, yet he had come expressly to be taught.
The difficulty was settled without a contest. Jerry promised to obey McEntire's directions. The teacher admitted him, and the account says he proved a docile pupil. There is no report of a struggle, a public test of strength, or an attempt to see whether the schoolmaster's original fear was justified. The arrangement worked because Jerry kept his word. Whatever his size, his interest in learning arithmetic turned out to be more consequential than the teacher's worry about punishment.
Other children attended the school from families whose names recur in the township's early history: Dipple, Unger, Jackson, Stewart and others. The history also records the economics of schooling, with teachers sometimes paid in produce and women receiving much lower fees than men. Eventually Matthew McMichael provided a frame schoolhouse for public use, and East Fallowfield developed institutions more recognizable to later generations. The shop with its greased-paper opening belonged to the earlier, improvised stage.
Of all those educational arrangements, the story of Jerry Gelvin is the one a reader is least likely to forget. It has everything needed for a small human comedy: a schoolmaster determined to preserve his authority, a student too big for the usual method of enforcement, and an agreement that allows both men to get on with the business of learning. McEntire taught while John worked the loom, and Jerry learned to cipher. The threatened whipping was never needed.