Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026
Cardiff Church and DeWitt Leads
Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.
Wescott research: new Cardiff church and De Witt leads
Editor’s assessment — 13 November 2026
Yes: the evidence supports a meaningful local connection and credible family hypotheses. It does not yet establish the proposed connection to Coral.
NEW SOURCE VERIFIED
Dwight H. Bruce, editor, Onondaga’s Centennial: Gleanings of a Century, volume II (Boston History Company, 1896), printed pp. 967, 971–972. University of Chicago Library copy digitized by Google; public scan hosted by genealogy.smcox.com. PDF pages 46, 52–53. Full scan and attributed page images preserved with this update.
https://genealogy.smcox.com/common/images/c/c7/Onondaga_s_Centennial.pdf
1. A shared church connection
Pages 971–972 describe Ebenezer Methodist Episcopal Church of Cardiff, organized in 1825, and list Grandus Cuddeback, Annanias Westcott, Reuben Wright, Benjamin D. Sniffen, and others among its original or early promoters. This is a retrospective published account, not a contemporary membership register. It does not date each person’s participation or identify relatives. The following paragraph concerns a DIFFERENT church, the Reformed Methodist society at Webb Hollow; those details must not be attributed to Cardiff.
Editor’s inference: this adds a social association to the land-record network already under study. Reuben Wright’s name also appears in the 1819 mortgage acknowledgment. The overlap is consistent with the same local Ananias, but the church account supplies no wife, age, or parentage to conclusively identify him. It supports community association more directly than biological relationship. Church attendance also offers a non-kin explanation for associations, so it cannot be treated as proof of a family tie.
2. A new maternal research route
Page 967 says Grandus Cuddeback’s wife was a niece of Major Moses De Witt. It does not give her name, her parents, or the side through which she was a niece. Graudis’s 1839 administration names his widow Jane, but identifying Jane as this unnamed wife requires additional evidence. Do not assign Jane the maiden name De Witt from this statement: a niece could be a sister’s daughter, and the relationship could be by marriage. Grandus/Graudis is a likely name variant in this locality, but identification remains an inference.
Research consequence: examine Major Moses De Witt’s will/estate and the estates, marriages, and baptisms of his siblings’ families for a niece married to Cuddeback/Cudeback/Cuttleback. This could identify Jane’s family, then provide independent records for Bethiah. No specific De Witt probate record was retrieved in this follow-up.
WEIGHT OF THE EXISTING EVIDENCE
Bethiah and Graudis: a credible, comparatively strong parentage hypothesis. Samuel and Bethiah’s one-sixth share in the estate land, parallel transfers by other couples, and Jane’s reserved dower fit an heirship pattern. The deeds establish a property interest; the petition, distribution, or another explicit relationship statement is still needed to settle whether Bethiah was Graudis’s daughter. Purchased interests and other routes of ownership have not been excluded.
Samuel and Ananias: a plausible hypothesis supported by the later family account naming Ananias as Samuel’s father, local land associations, and now this church association with the Cuddebacks. However, Samuel and Deborah were the couple in the earlier 94-acre lot 72 transactions; they must remain separate from Samuel and Bethiah. The new church passage does not resolve the two Samuels’ relationship or identify which Samuel was Ananias’s son.
Ananias and Coral: no specific genealogical bridge established. Coral’s documented line through George and Phebe Salisbury Wescott and George Washington Wescott remains distinct. The new material supports further investigation of the Onondaga families; it does not independently support attaching Ananias to Coral’s pedigree.
WHAT REMAINS OUTSTANDING
Graudis’s estate petition and distribution papers; Samuel and Bethiah’s purchase deed for lot 72; a direct relationship statement linking the two Samuel households; a documented connection to Coral’s ancestors. None was newly obtained in this follow-up.
NEXT SOURCES NOW BETTER TARGETED
• Cardiff Methodist class lists, membership/transfer records, marriages and baptisms, particularly the early congregation associated with Reuben Wright, Sniffen and Cuddeback. A directory lists LaFayette Methodist class books, but their dates, congregation and access were not verified; do not assume they are Cardiff records.
• De Witt collateral-family probate and church records, using the explicit niece statement as a lead rather than a pedigree fact.
• Graudis’s original estate file, especially heir lists and distribution receipts; retain the exact 28 March 1839 administration reference AA:441 and inventory date 13 April 1839.
• The missing lot 72 purchase deed, searching both Samuel households independently and distinguishing John Haynes from Robert Haynes.
SEARCH LIMITS
Targeted public-web searches did not identify an explicit Bethiah relationship record or a new Nichols probate. Exact-text searches of the online Caudebec in America transcription for Grandus, Graudis and Bethiah produced no matches; that is not an exhaustive surname-variant search. Modern copies of the same church history are not independent evidence.
IMAGE ATTRIBUTION
images/centennial-p967.png, images/centennial-p971.png and images/centennial-p972.png are full-page renders from the public-domain 1896 volume above. Google digitization and University of Chicago library provenance retained. No depicted person is identified as a Wescott ancestor.