Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026
What the evidence establishes—and what remains open
An official Perinton tax index lists George and Phebe Wescott in 1818. Newspaper text supplies a Samuel–Willett lead and a Westchester birthplace to investigate; the page images still need checking. The separate 1942 genealogical bulletin has been located as an archival target. No connection between the branches is proved. Read the evidence, access limits and next checks →
David Wescott Smith’s new Lewis extracts trace the Clarendon–Chautauqua family to Abram Salisbury Westcott and identify Phebe Salisbury’s own Westcott descent. This is a compiled lineage; the connection to Lloyd and Glenway remains unproved. Yale has confirmed both requests: order 1273902 for Folder 3347 (November 17) and order 1273901 for Folder 3471 (November 18). Confirmation is not delivery; the folder contents remain unexamined. Read the lineages, source distinctions, discrepancies and order status →
This is the current assessment. “Documented” refers to what a record actually states; “probable” and “hypothesis” identify interpretation. A published family history can preserve valuable testimony without proving each parent-child relationship.
Coral’s family and the Hampton branch
Coral names George and Phebe Salisbury → George Washington and Olive Waterman, then the Orris–Eugene–Roy branch. Lois’s archive identifies her as Roy and Geneva’s daughter and explicitly catalogs her report about Olive and George Washington. This is a direct research connection to Coral’s named family; it does not independently prove the whole pedigree.
Perinton, rather than “Pennington”?
The 1820 Perinton census, p. 344, names George Wescott, with one man aged 26–44, one woman aged 16–25 and two girls under ten. It follows Calvin Waterman Jr. and Calvin Waterman. Ages, place and household pattern fit George and Olive; the census does not name the women or girls. Preserve Coral’s “Pennington” wording while flagging Perinton as the stronger candidate.
Keep the two Samuel households separate
The 1819 mortgage names Samuel’s wife Deborah; Samuel and Deborah sell the 94-acre lot 72 tract to John Haynes in 1836. Those records must not be assigned to Samuel and Bethiah. The two households’ relationship remains unknown.
Bethiah’s estate interest
The 16 February 1841 deed conveys her one-sixth interest in Graudis Cudeback’s estate land, subject to widow Jane’s dower. It does not call Bethiah his daughter. Parallel estate shares strengthen an heirship hypothesis, but an explicit heir list or relationship statement remains needed.
Graudis’s estate
Letters AA:441, 28 March 1839, appoint Jane Cuddeback, widow, and Joshua Cuddeback as administrators. Graudis died intestate. Joshua’s relationship and the children are not stated. Index references identify an inventory filed 13 April 1839 and appraisers order A:86. The petition and distribution remain unretrieved.
Lot 72, Jackson and the missing purchase
Samuel and Bethiah mortgage two parcels to George Jackson on 15 March 1841; later sales in 1842 and 1846 trace those interests. Jackson’s nearby 1840 deed to Johnson Prine and his mortgage to Robert Haynes strengthen the geographic connection. No retrieved purchase deed establishes how Samuel acquired the parcels, and coordinated transactions do not establish kinship.
Ananias, Damaris and Samuel
The society compilation names Ananias as father of Samuel, Bethiah’s husband. Local deeds associate Ananias and Damaris with the older Samuel–Deborah household. A September 1843 deed places Ananias and Dameras in Nichols, Tioga County. No identified probate for that couple settles the relationship. The Bedford Ananias will reference dated 1824 remains a separate candidate, not a substitute.
Cardiff church and a De Witt lead
The 1896 county history names Grandus Cuddeback and Annanias Westcott among Cardiff church promoters and says Grandus’s wife was a niece of Major Moses De Witt. It does not name her or her parents. Do not assign Jane the maiden name De Witt. Community association is established more directly than kinship.
The proposed Hunterdon–Coral bridge
The November 17 Lewis selections strengthen the Clarendon side but add no link to Ananias or Samuel. See the full compiled descent and its verification limits.
No retrieved record connects Ananias or the Samuel households to Coral’s George and Phebe Salisbury. The Stephen route and an earlier seventh-cousin-twice-removed estimate are withdrawn as conclusions. Keep them out of a settled pedigree. Shared geography and musical traditions do not supply the missing generations.
Dates and identifications requiring correction
Olive’s death differs: Coral gives 14 April 1870; the Waterman genealogy gives 19 March 1886. Society excerpts disagree on Willett’s marriage year, Timothy’s death date and military details, and contain apparent Iowa/Ohio place errors. The Samuel/Bethiah photograph is only “believed to be” them. None is silently reconciled.
The fiddle’s inscription and missing portrait
The 1999 notice reports an 1884 Hampton inscription and a circa-1876 tintype. Neither the instrument nor tintype was inspected in this research. Holt’s Seattle auction does not establish Seattle residence; the 1999 notice calls him a Salem resident.
Belle and the Sumner letter
The 1967 quarterly identifies Belle as Mrs. George W. Wescott of Sumner; her later obituary recalls genealogical interests. This makes her a candidate author of the earlier Waterman-source letter, not its established author. The racehorse story belongs to the identified Sumner household.
Ada and the archive description
The archive calls Ada Mae Lois’s maternal grandmother, whereas the assembled Coral/Roy identification suggests the paternal side. Inspect the correspondence before resolving this. The cataloged 1918 suffrage poem does not establish its viewpoint or organizational membership.
The most useful next documents
- Lois’s 1990 Olive Waterman report and 1988 Hampton history, including Ada’s poem.
- Ada’s letters and identified family photographs, with captions and backs.
- Graudis’s estate petition, inventory and distribution, using AA:441 and A:86.
- Samuel and Bethiah’s lot 72 purchase deed, with parcel boundaries compared to the older household.
- Original Sumner correspondence cited in the Waterman genealogy.
Gwendolyn’s writing: what the evidence supports
- Original pages inspected: “Manhattan” and “Appointment”; the 1938 biography naming Roy Wescott and Geneva Moolick.
- Cataloged publications: a wider bibliography of poetry, fiction and nonfiction, with direct links in the story.
- Index evidence: the CBS reading of “Somehow.” The original notice and broadcast details remain unverified.
- Qualified identification: the circa-1937 office portrait is described by UNI as likely Gwendolyn.
- Not established: autobiographical readings of the poems, Ada’s influence on Gwendolyn, or any new Hunterdon bridge.
Read Gwendolyn’s story and excerpts · Inspect the source register.
Art and music: evidence and limits
Gene’s printmaking and poster stories are attributed to his published obituary. No original print or poster is reproduced. His 1962 mountaineering report is signed primary-source writing, but not proof of participation in every event it describes. The tune’s connection to the fiddle is documented in Lew Holt’s recollection; the composition belongs to Willie Doig and is not identified as music played by the fiddle’s maker. The recording link has been located but playback not independently checked. These additions enrich the Hampton branch; they do not establish a Hunterdon relationship.