Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026

Graudis Probate and Lot72

Editor’s note · 13 November 2026

Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.

Editor’s evidence update · 13 November 2026

Result: Graudis Cuddeback’s 1839 letters of administration have been retrieved. Samuel and Bethiah’s 1841 mortgage and their 1846 disposal of the remaining land have also been retrieved. Their purchase deed remains unfound. These records strengthen the geographic and property connection, but do not prove a relationship between the Samuel–Deborah and Samuel–Bethiah households, or connect Ananias to Coral’s line.

Graudis’s probate: an identified estate, not a will

Documented: Onondaga letters, book AA, p. 441, dated 28 March 1839, appoint Jane Cuddeback, widow, and Joshua Cuddeback administrators of Graudis’s estate. The recorded entry says he had lately died intestate. It gives no precise death date and no list of children. The appointment does not specify Joshua’s relationship to Graudis. The index renders the given name Grandis; the handwritten letters are consistent with Graudis. Cudeback/Cuddeback and Graudis/Grandis/Grandus should all be searched.

View the administration record at FamilySearch · View at FamilySearch. DGS 005116330, image 267 of 297. The jurisdiction clause allows either residence or assets in the county; the later estate deeds more specifically identify the deceased as late of La Fayette.

Additional probate references located: the general probate index, p. 168, records an inventory filed 13 April 1839 and order appointing appraisers, book A, p. 86. These are references to further records, not records retrieved in this update. The appointment-column heading must not be mistaken for a final settlement. Both halves of the index are preserved: names and letters; inventory and appraisers.

Editor’s interpretation: the shared widow’s name, surname, county and timing strongly identify this as the estate referred to in the 1841–1842 land conveyances. The next useful probate material is the petition, inventory, administration bond, accounting and distribution papers. A petition or distribution schedule may name the heirs. The inventory alone may concern goods and debts rather than relationships. An earlier search result for Abraham A. Cuddeback’s 1832 will concerns a different estate and supplies no proof for Graudis’s family.

Who held interests in Graudis’s land?

ConveyorsEvidenceWhat it establishes
Samuel and Bethiah Wescott16 February 1841; $500; one-sixth of lot 57, subdivision 7, 104 acres 45 perches; subject to Jane’s dower. Previously retrieved estate deed.They conveyed an estate interest. Bethiah’s precise relationship is not expressly stated.
Thomas and Matilda ParksAdjacent 1841 deed in the previously retrieved image; one-sixth interest.Another couple in the division; kinship requires separate proof.
Joshua C. and Lovicy Cudeback16 February 1841; $500; one-sixth; same parcel and widow’s dower; recorded 4 May 1841. pp. 180–181.Explicitly describes Joshua’s right in the deceased’s estate. Does not say “son.”
Oliver and Elizabeth Hester3 June 1842; $500; all their right in the estate’s lot 57 land to Timothy and Rachel Cuddeback. p. 179.An additional estate interest; Elizabeth also appears as Betty in the opening. No explicit daughter statement.
H. G. / Gridly and Fanny Northway3 June 1842; $500; same estate land to Timothy and Rachel; recorded 18 June. Opening; p. 180 continuation.Another interest in the same estate. Expanded form of the husband’s name needs further checking.

Hypothesis, not established pedigree: these deeds are consistent with Timothy consolidating interests from a family group, potentially six inheritance shares including his own. They do not by themselves establish six children, nor exclude acquired interests or representation through a deceased heir. Bethiah’s surname in the family history, the matching estate interest and her son Graudis’s name are mutually consistent clues. The proof still needs an explicit relationship record or a fully resolved inheritance analysis.

Lot 72: stronger continuity, purchase deed still missing

The earlier records identify a 94-acre parcel jointly bought by Ananias and Samuel in 1819. The mortgage names their wives as Damaris and Deborah. Ananias and Damaris conveyed their interest to Samuel in 1821; Samuel and Deborah conveyed the 94 acres to John Haynes in 1836. See the prior image-based assessment.

DateNewly established recordMeaning and limitation
9 March 1840George and Hannah Jackson mortgage 94 acres in lot 72 to Robert Haynes for $2,150. The description repeats the hemlock, Sniffin, creek, Gideon Seely, 56-chain-70-link west course and 16-chain-16-link north course. p. 379.Strong evidence of the earlier tract passing into the Jackson/Haynes title network. This is a mortgage, not the deed transferring ownership to Jackson. Only its opening was downloaded.
15 March 1841Samuel and Bethiah mortgage to George Jackson two parcels in lot 72: 17 acres 4 rods and 29 acres 37 rods, securing $1,063, payable in five equal annual payments with annual interest. Acknowledged 16 March 1841; recorded 26 March 1842. p. 337; p. 338.Proves Bethiah’s husband held and mortgaged these interests by this date. George Jackson is a strong seller candidate, but the mortgage does not itself prove he sold the land or that it was purchase-money financing.
24 March 1842Samuel and Bethiah sell the 17-acre parcel plus five acres to Robert Haynes. George and Hannah Jackson separately sell Haynes 47 acres bounded by Samuel’s land. p. 176–177; p. 178.Same-day transactions and adjoining boundaries support a subdivision of the former tract. They do not establish kinship among the sellers or the Haynes men.
28 August 1846Samuel and Bethiah sell the remaining western tract, stated as 29 acres 30 perches less five acres, retaining the previously conveyed passage right for Haynes. $525; acknowledgment same day; recorded 24 January 1848. p. 407; p. 408.Connects their remaining land to their earlier Haynes sale. The buyer’s name is faint and is not normalized here. The 30-perch versus 37-rod discrepancy remains unresolved. Late recording does not place the couple in New York in 1848.

Search limits: full-text searches for Wescott/Westcott, George Jackson and distinctive boundary language did not yield the purchase deed. The grantee index pages 2656 and 2657, covering the inspected We- entries for 1836–1849, include Samuel’s 1838 purchase from J. T. Card of lot 57 (book 70, p. 424), but no identified lot 72 purchase. This is a bounded negative finding. An omitted or later index entry, another spelling, an unrecorded deed or a different title instrument remains possible. The grantor index under Jackson and the complete Haynes title chain are not exhausted.

The two Samuels and Coral’s line

Documented: one Samuel appears with Deborah in 1819 and 1836; another research identity appears with Bethiah in 1841, 1842 and 1846. The overlap with the compilation’s 1826 Samuel–Bethiah marriage still supports treating them as separate men. The new mortgage links Bethiah’s husband to land associated with Ananias and Samuel–Deborah through intervening Jackson/Haynes interests. It does not supply a parent, sibling, uncle or cousin relationship.

Not established: Ananias of Pompey/Nichols as father of Samuel (1802–1904); the relationship between the two Samuel households; a connection from this Ananias to Coral’s George/Phebe Salisbury and George Washington/Olive Waterman line. The compilation and 1910 biography remain clues to Samuel’s father, not a resolution of the two households. No new evidence here changes Coral’s documented/compiled branch or justifies adding Ananias to it.

Next records with the greatest potential: (1) Graudis’s 1839 estate petition and distribution papers, using AA:441, inventory filed 13 April and appraisers A:86; (2) Jackson’s grantor index and the conveyances into and out of his 94-acre holding, especially around March 1840–March 1841; (3) Samuel–Deborah’s later residence and estate, separately from Samuel–Bethiah; (4) probate for Ananias and Damaris after their September 1843 Nichols deed, and evidence identifying Coral’s earlier George’s parents. These are research targets, not obtained records.

Original county images are the evidence; FamilySearch’s included automated transcripts contain errors and remain unaltered. Nine additional source PDFs and four index images are preserved with citations and hashes in the source register (retained in the private research package). This is a local editorial update; no live publication or family-tree changes were made.

Editor’s latest follow-up: estate papers still outstanding. Jackson’s 1840 Prine deed and mortgage continuation are now preserved, with grantor and grantee index checks. A matching March 16, 1841 acknowledgment date strengthens the land-transaction association; it does not establish kinship. Graudis’s petition/distribution, Bethiah’s parentage, the two Samuels’ relationship, and the bridge to Coral remain unproved. Read the follow-up, search limits and precise estate-file request.