Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026

Estate Petition and Jackson Deeds

Editor’s note · 13 November 2026

Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.

Editor’s evidence update · 13 November 2026

Result: The requested estate petition and distribution papers have not been retrieved. The new work preserves Jackson’s complete 1840 deed to Johnson Prine, completes his 1840 mortgage to Robert Haynes, and checks both Jackson deed indexes. No new record proves Bethiah’s parentage or the relationship between the two Samuel households. Ananias’s connection to Coral’s line remains unproved.

What the new Jackson records establish

Documented: George Jackson and Hannah his wife, of La Fayette, conveyed one acre in lot 72 to Johnson Prine for $50 by deed dated 30 October 1840. The parcel begins at a stake east of the creek on William Sniffin’s south boundary, runs west 4 chains 70 links to the road, south 19 degrees east along the road 2 chains 60 links, east 3 chains 4 links to the creek, then north 17 degrees east 2 chains 57 links to the beginning. This is the same local neighborhood described in Samuel and Bethiah’s mortgage.

The deed was acknowledged 16 March 1841 before Abiel Davison and recorded 18 January 1842. Citation: Onondaga deeds 80:37–38, FamilySearch DGS 007174461, images 345–346. Opening and boundary description · Continuation, acknowledgment and recording · Online image.

Editor’s inference: the acknowledgment date matches 16 March 1841 in Samuel and Bethiah’s mortgage to George Jackson, dated 15 March. Together with the shared boundaries, this supports coordinated land transactions. It does not establish that Jackson sold Samuel the parcels, that the mortgage financed a purchase, or that any of the parties were relatives.

Documented: the continuation of Jackson and Hannah’s 9 March 1840 mortgage to Robert Haynes confirms acknowledgment on 14 March 1840 before Abiel Davison and recording on 3 April 1840. The opening describes 94 acres; the continuation supplies the execution and recording details but no prior title recital or kinship. p. 379, previously retrieved · p. 380, newly retrieved. DGS 007173631, images 530–531.

What the deed indexes do—and do not—show

Index checkedObserved entries and limit
Jackson grantors, p. 1233; recorded years 1835–1847. DGS 007173165, image 23.George and Hannah to J. Prine, 80:37, Pompey lot 72; George and Hannah to R. Haynes, 81:177, Pompey lot 72. Both are listed under 1842, their recording year. No Jackson-to-Samuel entry was identified on this page. The page also lists George by a master to R. McIntyre, 84:487, La Fayette lot 87; that is a different lot and is not adopted as part of lot 72. Full index image.
Jackson grantees, p. 1233; recorded years 1831–1850. DGS 007173181, image 23.No identified George Jackson acquisition of Pompey lot 72. An earlier George entry from R. Steele is Salina land, not this tract. Full index image.

Editor’s assessment: the expected purchase deed remains missing from both sides of the immediate index trail. This is a bounded negative finding, not proof that no deed existed. Later recording, another spelling, an omitted index entry, an unrecorded instrument, or an intermediate transfer remains possible. The earlier Wescott grantee checks and these Jackson pages do not exhaust the 1794–1870 indexes. Jackson remains a possible seller; he is not a documented seller to Samuel.

Graudis’s petition and distribution: retrieval status

The verified estate anchor remains letters of administration AA:441, 28 March 1839, appointing Jane Cuddeback, expressly called widow, and Joshua Cuddeback. Joshua’s relationship is not stated. The general index, p. 168, refers to an inventory filed 13 April 1839 and order appointing appraisers A:86. Those references identify a real estate administration, but they are not the petition, inventory contents, accounting or distribution. See the previous evidence report and administration image.

Additional source examinedResult and limit
Miscellaneous orders and decrees, BB, 1838–1850; DGS 005116338.Search Cud*back returned seven images across the mixed 1864–1865/1838–1850 film. Matches concern Egbert D., DeWitt, Levi and James Cuddeback. The BB C-surname index at image 120 lists DeWitt, Levi and James; no Graudis entry was identified. Preserved index. This is not an examination of every entry in the volume or of later settlement volumes.
Disposition of real estate, A–B, 1831–1881; DGS 005116342.Cud*back returned three images mentioning Isaiah or Moses Cuddeback, not an identified Graudis estate proceeding. Full-text retrieval can miss handwriting and spelling variants; this is not an exhaustive negative.
Proceedings in dower, A, 1830–1879; DGS 005116349.Cud*back returned no results. Jane’s private dower release or a differently indexed proceeding could still exist.
Lester Card’s surrogate abstracts, 1795–1842; DGS 007832391.Cud*back returned eight matches in a mixed-content film; the result list did not identify Graudis’s estate. These are typescripts, not the original estate packet, and all eight images were not individually inspected.
Abstracts of intestate records, Grace B. Lodder from Lester Card’s notes; film 908977 item 22, DGS 007941272.The signed-in catalog explicitly reports that this item is not currently digitally accessible because of access restrictions; microfilm is listed at the FamilySearch Library. Its contents and Graudis coverage remain unknown.
Official WebSurrogate.The welcome page states that document-image links are for filings on or after 19 February 2014, with older unrestricted documents viewable at the court. The search-options page requires a CAPTCHA, so no estate-name search was submitted. Historical index availability varies by court. This route did not retrieve the 1839 packet.

Access conclusion: no original petition or distribution file was located in the accessible holdings checked. It would be incorrect to say these papers do not survive, or that no distribution occurred. The next concrete retrieval is a search by the Onondaga County Surrogate’s Court for the original filed papers and any final accounting, using the precise references already found. The New York State Archives’ description of surrogate records distinguishes recorded volumes from filed petitions, inventories and accountings. A ready-to-use records request (retained in the private research package) is included; it has not been sent.

Does this prove Bethiah’s parentage?

No. The earlier 1841 deed documents Samuel and Bethiah conveying a one-sixth interest in the Graudis estate land to Timothy Cudeback, subject to widow Jane’s dower. The companion transfers by Joshua and Lovicy, Thomas and Matilda Parks, Oliver and Elizabeth/Betty Hester, and H. G. and Fanny Northway strengthen the possibility of a family division. They do not explicitly call Bethiah a daughter. An inherited interest, an acquired interest, or a right held through another person must be distinguished before calling this proof of parentage.

Working hypothesis: Bethiah belonged to Graudis’s immediate family and may have been his daughter. The estate petition, a list of heirs or next of kin, receipts specifying relationships, or a distribution decree could resolve this. The newly retrieved Jackson papers add no evidence about her parents.

Do the records explain the two Samuels or connect Coral?

No family relationship is yet proved. Keep Samuel with Deborah (1819 and 1836 records) separate from Samuel with Bethiah (1841 onward records) pending evidence explaining their identities and the overlapping marriage chronology. The land chain now contains an intervening Jackson/Haynes network. That makes shared land less diagnostic of direct inheritance or a father–son transfer between the Samuels.

The 1819 Ananias–Samuel joint transaction and 1821 Ananias–Damaris conveyance to Samuel remain documented associations, without explicit kinship. The later biography naming Ananias as father of Samuel born in 1802 remains a retrospective clue. Graudis’s papers, even if they prove Bethiah’s father, would not automatically establish Samuel’s father or identify the older Samuel.

Coral’s branch remains separate: George and Phebe Salisbury → George Washington Wescott and Olive Waterman → Orris → Eugene. Nothing retrieved in this follow-up supplies a documented bridge from the Pompey/Nichols Ananias to that line. No pedigree merger or new parent assignment is warranted.

Next targeted work: obtain the original Graudis filed papers; trace the transfer from John Haynes, who bought Samuel–Deborah’s 94 acres in 1836, to Robert Haynes/Jackson; check later-recorded Jackson and Wescott acquisition entries; and seek Ananias–Damaris records after their September 1843 Nichols deed. These are specific outstanding tasks, not completed searches.

This supplement adds three record PDFs and three index images. Original image copies and machine transcripts are preserved separately from the editorial interpretation. See the updated source register (retained in the private research package) and image attribution (retained in the private research package).