Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026
Pompey and Nichols
Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.
Editor’s evidence update · 13 November 2026 · Second probate and land follow-up
This update corrects the earlier ranking of the Pompey couple as a converging parentage lead. It adds seven downloaded record-image PDFs, preserves bounded probate-index checks, and distinguishes image-verified evidence from unchecked search leads. Sources are county recorded copies, not original signed instruments. FamilySearch’s accompanying machine transcripts are preserved unaltered; several readings are wrong.
The decisive identity evidence
The recorded mortgage abstract dated 6 July 1819, Onondaga mortgages, Liber F, pp. 439–440, describes Ananias Westcott of Pompey and Damaris his wife, and Samuel Westcott of the same place and Deborah his wife, as mortgagors to Jacob Ryder. It secures $380.56 on the same 94-acre lot 72 purchase. The acknowledgment on 7 July 1819 again pairs each husband and wife; Reuben Wright identifies them to the officer. Recording was 26 July 1819. Opening, p. 439; acknowledgment, p. 440.
A discharge recorded 8 June 1833, Liber Z, p. 353, independently points back to that mortgage and again names the two couples. This is a discharge of a prior obligation, not evidence that all borrowers were still alive in 1833. Discharge image.
The 7 April 1836 deed, recorded 5 July 1837, then names Samuel Wescott and Deborah his wife as sellers of the 94 acres to John Haynes for $1,880. Book 67, pp. 207–208. The continuation includes Deborah’s separate acknowledgment. Opening; continuation. Another digitization of the opening has a clearer automated rendering of Haynes, initially misread as Hays in the research notes; the report uses Haynes.
Editor’s interpretation: the surviving 1819 and 1836 instruments support a Samuel–Deborah research identity. The family compilation’s Samuel–Bethiah marriage in 1826 and their child chronology overlap the later Samuel–Deborah deed. Two men are the working explanation. A change of wife alone cannot explain that overlap without additional evidence. The earlier “Samuel would have been seventeen” observation is no longer the principal issue: the named wives are the stronger conflict. No deed examined calls Ananias and Samuel father and son.
Lot 72: the chain established so far
| Date / instrument | Documented transaction | Identity or title limitation |
|---|---|---|
| 6 July 1819 purchase | Jacob and Margaret Ryder → Ananias and Samuel Wescott; 94 acres, lot 72, Pompey; $658. p. 577, p. 578. | The same-day mortgage supplies wives Damaris and Deborah. It states no kinship. |
| 6–7 July 1819 mortgage | Ananias–Damaris and Samuel–Deborah → Jacob Ryder; purchase-money obligation of $380.56. Ryder assigns it to Philip Van Cortlandt on 7 July. | The land is spelled “Seventy two” on the image, although the machine transcript says seventy five. |
| 9 June 1821 conveyance; acknowledged 3 April 1833; recorded 8 June 1833 | Ananias and Damaris → Samuel; the 94-acre tract; $120. Book 51, p. 332. | Consistent with consolidation of the jointly purchased property. Not a statement of parentage; do not identify the grantee as Bethiah’s husband without more evidence. |
| 8 June 1833 discharge | The 1819 mortgage is discharged of record. | Does not establish a new transfer or a death date. |
| 7 April 1836 sale; recorded 5 July 1837 | Samuel and Deborah → John Haynes; 94 acres; $1,880. | A crucial intervening transfer. A direct Ananias → Samuel–Bethiah title chain has not been shown. |
| 24 March 1842 sale; recorded 18 June 1842 | Samuel and Bethiah → Robert Haynes; 17 acres and four rods plus a five-acre parcel in lot 72; $650. pp. 176–177. | Smaller parcels repeat the hemlock/Sniffin starting boundary. Their acquisition instrument has not been identified. The relationship between John and Robert Haynes is not established here. |
The missing link: the instrument or instruments by which Samuel, husband of Bethiah, acquired his lot 72 interests. Search the grantee index for Samuel under Wescott, Westcott and Waiscott, and the grantor index for John Haynes and later owners. The common starting boundary is geographically meaningful, but the 94-acre tract and the later smaller parcels must be plotted and their title interests reconciled. Bearing differences in the copies also deserve comparison; matching descriptions are not proof of kinship.
Ananias and Damaris: a move to Nichols
A deed dated and acknowledged 2 September 1843 identifies Ananias Wescott and Dameras his wife, of Nichols, Tioga County, New York. They sell a half-acre parcel in lot 57 of the original township of Pompey, now La Fayette, to Andrew Phares. It was recorded 13 February 1847, Onondaga deeds, book 92, p. 25. Record image and supplied citation.
Documented: this named couple were living and acknowledged a deed in September 1843; their stated residence was Nichols. The 1847 recording date does not establish survival to 1847. Strong identity hypothesis: the rare husband-and-wife name pairing and retained Onondaga property point toward the earlier Pompey couple. A complete lot 57 acquisition chain would strengthen that identification. If continuous, it rules out assigning this man the death in 1833 attributed to the Bedford candidate. It does not yet prove his birth, parents, or children.
The Nichols residence makes Tioga a necessary estate-search jurisdiction. Damaris’s maiden name and both death dates remain unresolved. Younger men named Ananias in Tioga and Wisconsin must not be merged into this older couple.
Bethiah’s inheritance opens a second probate route
On 16 February 1841, Samuel Waiscott and Bethiah his wife, of La Fayette, conveyed to Timothy Cudeback for $500 one equal sixth of a parcel of 104 acres and 45 perches, subdivision 7 of lot 57, original Pompey. The deed expressly describes the share as Bethiah’s right in the estate of Graudis Cudeback, deceased, subject to the dower right of Jane Cudeback, his widow. The given name is handwritten and appears as “Graudis”; variants Grandis/Graudis/Cudeback/Cuddeback should be retained in searches. Acknowledged 23 February; recorded 4 May 1841, p. 176. Record image.
Documented relationship: Bethiah held an estate interest; Jane was the deceased’s widow. Not explicitly stated: Bethiah was his daughter, Timothy was her brother, or Jane was her mother. The adjacent Thomas and Matilda Parks conveyance describes Matilda’s one-sixth interest in the same estate. These are excellent people to compare in probate, but equal shares alone do not prove sibling relationships.
The estate should have arisen by February 1841. Its will, administration, partition or heirship proceedings may identify Bethiah with a maiden name and residence, clarifying the Samuel–Bethiah household independently of the older Samuel–Deborah household. The repeated Graudis name in the later Wescott family is consistent with this lead, not independent proof.
Probate search: what was and was not found
No probate record for the elder Ananias or Damaris has been identified in this follow-up. This is an incomplete search result, not evidence that no estate existed. The saved index pages are finding aids and are not probate files for this couple.
- Onondaga: bounded visual review of the general probate index, S–Z, 1802–1923, included pp. 813–815, with West/Westcott entries on 814–815. No matching Ananias or Damaris was located on those pages. Later continuations, spelling variations, guardianship material and earlier record series have not been exhausted.
- Tioga: visually checked the opening W page of the will/proceeding index, image 161, p. 149, with entries spanning approximately 1809–1867; no matching couple. Also checked administration/guardianship index images 76–77, pp. 67–68. No Ananias/Damaris match located there; Polly J. Westcott appears as a separate, unconnected lead on p. 68. These faint, mixed index entries and subsequent continuation pages still require a systematic review.
- Full-text searches: Ananias and Damaris name searches produced land and unrelated same-name leads, not an identified estate. A Damaris Wescott result described broadly as cemetery material actually proved to be a Glens Falls Methodist membership list for 1862, printed p. 234. It supplies no spouse or age and has not been connected to Pompey.
- Bedford: the previously retrieved 1834 deed referring to Ananias’s will dated 20 February 1824 remains a separate candidate record. That will itself remains unretrieved; Abraham’s 1786/1791 will is not a substitute for it.
The search log (retained in the private research package) gives the exact inspected index images and limitations. The expanded source register (retained in the private research package) gives the downloaded record citations and file hashes.
Does any of this reach Coral’s line?
No documented connection has emerged. The revised working model keeps three questions separate: (1) who were the parents of Samuel, husband of Bethiah; (2) how were the older Samuel–Deborah and Ananias–Damaris households related, if at all; and (3) whether any of them connect to George Wescott and Phebe Salisbury in Coral’s ancestry.
The existing Coral-side narrative runs George and Phebe Salisbury → George Washington Wescott and Olive Waterman → Orris Waterman Wescott → Eugene Merritt Wescott. The previously inspected Waterman Family (1939), p. 424, supports George Washington’s parentage and Clarendon birth, but does not connect George to Ananias. Preserved page 424. The 1910 Graudis Wescott biography names an Ananias as father of Samuel born in 1802, but does not identify him as this Pompey/Nichols man or explain the Samuel–Deborah household. Neither source supplies a common ancestor or a cousin degree.
Specific unresolved records with the best payoff
- Samuel–Bethiah’s acquisition of lot 72: find the grantee entry and deed before their March 1842 sale; follow John Haynes after the 1836 purchase and compare parcel boundaries. Do not assume a conveyance back to Samuel occurred.
- Ananias–Damaris after 1843: establish their deaths and household using Nichols/Tioga census, land and burial records, then complete both will and administration indexes. If either died elsewhere, move the probate search with the evidence.
- Graudis Cudeback’s estate before February 1841: seek the complete heirs list and the remaining one-sixth conveyances, using Jane, Timothy and Matilda Parks as associates.
- Coral’s earliest securely identified couple: pursue George and Phebe Salisbury Wescott’s Clarendon deeds/probate and the Waterman source correspondence. A bridge should rest on named relationships, not shared surname or New England origin.
All access in this follow-up was 13 November 2026. New editorial notes are labeled and do not alter Coral’s historical narrative. Local research files only; no live website publication.