Editor’s research update · 17 November 2026

Clarendon to Chautauqua: a stronger lineage, an open Hunterdon question

Supporting-records follow-up · 17 November 2026

An official Perinton tax index lists George and Phebe Wescott in 1818. Newspaper text supplies a Samuel–Willett lead and a Westchester birthplace to investigate; the page images still need checking. The separate 1942 genealogical bulletin has been located as an archival target. No connection between the branches is proved. Read the evidence, access limits and next checks →

David Wescott Smith’s new selections identify a continuous compiled line to Abram Salisbury Westcott. They do not yet connect that family to Lloyd and Glenway Wescott.

Evidence status

The line below is documented in genealogical compilations. That is different from verifying every generation in original birth, marriage, probate or land records. No common ancestor with the Hunterdon branch, and no cousin degree, is established by the material reviewed here.

The Clarendon–Chautauqua line

Smith, historian of the Society of Stukely Westcott Descendants of America, explained on November 17 that the numbers in the society’s Clarendon cemetery account refer to individuals in Edna Lewis’s The Westcott Family Tree, the “Red Book.” They are not cemetery plot numbers. His 20-page PDF supplies a two-page chart and the corresponding book extracts. [1]

Read each arrow as a parent–child relationship asserted by Lewis’s compilation:

  1. Stukely Westcott and Juliana Marchant (entry 1) → Jeremiah Westcott (6).
  2. Jeremiah Westcott and Eleanor England → Jeremiah Westcott Jr. (20).
  3. Jeremiah Jr. and Mary Ann Warner → George Westcott (49), born about 1694.
  4. George and Elizabeth → George Westcott Jr. (114), born April 1730.
  5. George Jr. and Phebe Wade → George Wescott III (207), 1762–1799.
  6. George III and Phebe Salisbury (297) → George Washington Wescott (369), 1793–1869.
  7. George Washington and Olive Waterman → Abram Salisbury Westcott (611), born March 7, 1826, Hamburg, New York; later associated with Blockville in Chautauqua County.

Exact source trail: Smith’s chart, PDF pp. 1–2; Lewis entries 1, 6, 20, 49, 114, 207, 297 and 369 in PDF pp. 3, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14–16; entry 611 on PDF p. 18, printed p. 119. Entry 369 (printed p. 76) lists Abram among George and Olive’s children; entry 611 repeats his ancestry and identifies his wife as Lucy Minor Burlingame. The compilation qualifies its explanation of Lucy’s surname as probable. [1]

Phebe Salisbury has a second Westcott descent

The chart also traces Jeremiah and Eleanor → William Westcott (24), husband of Abigail Gardiner → Ezekiel Westcott (69), husband of Mary Dyer → Zilpha “Sophie” Westcott (155), wife of Abraham Salisbury → Phebe Salisbury (297), wife of George III. This is a second compiled descent within the Clarendon family; it supplies no missing Hunterdon generation. See PDF pp. 1, 7, 9, 11 and 14–15, printed pp. 8, 18, 34 and 62–63. [1]

The migration and the collateral branch

Entry 369 places the first two children in “Perrinton,” New York, in 1819 and 1820; later children in Hamburg in 1822–1826; and children in Harmony, Chautauqua County, beginning in 1828. These compiled birthplaces strengthen the existing Perinton research lead but do not independently prove a move date. Abram and Orris Waterman Wescott (613) are listed as brothers. Entry 613, printed p. 120, names Eugene Merritt Wescott among Orris’s children, tying this material to the separately researched Hampton/fiddle branch. [1] Earlier census assessment.

Primary records to check next

Lewis entry 207 cites Clarendon marriage records, book 2, p. 35, old film number 7172, and Revolutionary pension file W6455, Rhode Island line, with bounty-land reference 18208-160-55. These are retrieval references, not records newly inspected in this update. A separate online transcription lists George Westcot and Phebe Salsbury married September 9, 1784, by Increase Mosely, J.P.; it corroborates the compiled marriage but remains a derivative transcription. Entry 114 points to the December 1942 genealogical bulletin and a revised child list from Ziba Westcott’s Bible; the original Bible and that bulletin have not been checked here. [1] [4]

The Hunterdon branch, traced separately

Samuel Wescott (1802–1904) and Bethiah Cuddeback → Willett Rainer Wescott and Kate Ross → Bruce Peters Wescott and Josephine Louella Gordon → Glenway and Lloyd Bruce Wescott.

The retained scans of Our Wescott Family Story, printed pp. 132–133, explicitly identify Samuel and Bethiah as Willett’s parents and Willett and Kate as Bruce’s parents. Printed p. 133 names Ananias as Samuel’s father, gives an unconfirmed birth year in angle brackets, and leaves Samuel’s mother unnamed. These are compiled assertions, not an inspected birth or probate record establishing Samuel’s parents. Lloyd’s account on printed p. 3 reports a possible Stukely descent from correspondence with an unnamed woman in Rhode Island; it does not supply a verifiable chain of intervening generations. The retained scans were re-examined for this update. [5]

A contemporary society death notice provides another source for the recent generation: Westcott Family Quarterly, March 1954, p. 2, identifies Bruce Peters Wescott as father of Lloyd and author Glenway, names his wife as the former Josephine Gordon, and reports his death at Flemington on November 18, 1953. This is contemporary reporting, not a civil birth certificate, and its informant is not identified. It does not establish Bruce’s earlier ancestry. [6]

The two Samuel households must remain separate

The existing original-record research is decisive about the names on the instruments: Onondaga mortgage book F, pp. 439–440 (July 1819), pairs Ananias with Damaris and Samuel with Deborah. The April 1836 sale, book 67, pp. 207–208, again pairs Samuel and Deborah. Samuel and Bethiah appear in separate 1841–1846 transactions. These county recorded copies establish transactions and spouses; no cited deed calls Ananias the father of Bethiah’s husband. Shared property or neighborhood does not repair that gap. Record analysis and images; mortgage citation; 1836 deed citation.

Assessment: identify Samuel–Bethiah’s parents independently, then test whether that family joins George–Phebe’s line. Do not substitute the older Samuel–Deborah household, merge the Pompey/Nichols Ananias with the Bedford candidate, revive the unsupported Stephen route, or calculate a cousin degree. The evidence reviewed establishes neither a shared colonial ancestor nor a later migration connecting the two branches.

Discrepancies retained for verification

  • Olive’s death: Lewis gives March 19, 1886, agreeing with the previously cited Waterman genealogy; Coral’s April 14, 1870 remains a documented conflict. Agreement between compilations may reflect shared sources.
  • Phebe versus Sarah Salisbury: Lewis entry 207 names Phebe as George III’s wife, but entry 155 lists Sarah Salisbury marrying a George Westcott on the same September 9, 1784 date. The marriage transcription names Phebe. The underlying register and pension file should resolve the inconsistency; do not invent two marriages.
  • Cemetery dates: Lewis gives Diana’s death as April 24, 1838; the society transcription gives April 21. Lewis gives Phebe Jane’s death as May 4, 1837; the transcription gives May 1. Jeremiah’s compiled June 5, 1785 birth also conflicts with the transcribed age 73 at death in August 1856. Stones and original vital records need comparison.
  • Book date: Smith’s November 14 email says 1990; his November 17 email and chart say 1999. This update uses the supplied chart’s 1999 attribution, pending inspection of the title/copyright page.

Sources: Lewis entries 155, 207, 368–369; Smith’s correspondence; society cemetery transcription. [1] [2] [3]

Yale: what is actually ordered

Yale’s November 17 confirmation for order 1273902 lists YCAL MSS 134, Box 339, Folder 3347. The finding aid identifies it as “Wescott Family Tree,” September 22, 1976. The confirmation states no charge and an average reference-PDF turnaround of four to six weeks. Counted from November 17, that suggests December 15–29, 2026, not a guaranteed delivery date. Yale’s general digitization webpage currently lists 10–14 weeks for documents, while this order-specific email says 4–6 weeks for PDFs; retain both statements and use the confirmation as the order-specific estimate. No scans from this order were available in the correspondence reviewed. [7]

Box 350, Folder 3471 (“Wescott genealogy info.”): order 1273901 confirmed November 18, 2026. Yale’s email confirms the separate request for YCAL MSS 134, Series IV: Personal Papers. Reference PDFs have an estimated four-to-six-week turnaround, subject to conservation assessment and delays. This confirms the order, not delivery, examination, reproduction permission, or any genealogical relationship.

Smith’s November 14 email promised Whitman annotations, Lewis extracts and review of the society’s Glenway folder, which includes a Lloyd letter to Betty Acker. His November 17 message delivers the Clarendon material and says review of Whitman’s annotations and the Lloyd/Glenway side is still ahead. Those promised materials are not evidence already received. [2]

Source register for this update

  1. Compiled genealogy, received and inspected. David Wescott Smith, “Clarendon Vermont Wescotts,” email, November 17, 2026, with 2026_11_17 Selections from the Westcott Family Tree.pdf, 20 pages. Chart credits Edna Lewis, The Westcott Family Tree (Rutland, Vermont: 1999). Citations above distinguish PDF page from printed book page. Original attachment retained in the private research files; not republished here.
  2. Research correspondence. Smith, November 14, 2026, “Re: Copies of Whitman annotations for Clarendon Wescotts and Ananias”; Smith, November 17 email; existing November 17 sent reply. Correspondence establishes what was supplied or promised, not the truth of every pedigree statement.
  3. Cemetery transcription. SSWDA, West Clarendon Cemetery, transcription attributed to Doug Wescott, accessed November 17, 2026. Transcribed inscriptions and genealogical identifications have different evidentiary weight; the underlying stones were not newly inspected.
  4. Marriage transcription. New Horizons Genealogy, Clarendon marriage records, 1779–1799, copied by Lynn Tooley, George Westcot–Phebe Salsbury entry, September 9, 1784; accessed November 17, 2026. Original register image not retrieved in this update.
  5. Family compilation with attributed recollections. Our Wescott Family Story, retained 17-page society selection, especially printed pp. 3, 131–134 and 163–164. Chapter 13 is attributed to Sybil Barrows Albrecht Lewis; its introduction says angle brackets indicate unconfirmed dates. The supplied title page is undated; Google Books catalogs the volume as 2002. Scanned pedigree pages were re-examined; catalog metadata is not a substitute for their contents.
  6. Contemporary published notice. Westcott Family Quarterly, March 1954, vol. XXI, no. 81, p. 2, Bruce Peters Wescott death notice. Does not name his parents.
  7. Archive description and administrative correspondence. Yale Beinecke, Glenway Wescott Papers finding aid, YCAL MSS 134, printed pp. 144 and 148; Folder 3471 catalog record; November 13 inquiry and Tom Cahill reply; November 17 confirmation, transaction 1273902; November 18 confirmation, transaction 1273901; general digitization guidance, accessed November 17, 2026. Gmail searches included the transaction number, both folder identifiers and Yale order confirmations, including All Mail/Spam/Trash. Folder contents have not yet been examined.