Research follow-up · 17 November 2026
Following the records: Perinton and Samuel Wescott
An official tax index supports the Perinton lead. Contemporary newspaper text strengthens the Samuel–Willett trail and points toward Westchester County. The connection between the two Wescott branches remains unproved.
We distinguish an inspected archive index or publication from an original record, searchable newspaper text from a checked page image, and a family-identification hypothesis from a demonstrated relationship. None of the new sources establishes Samuel’s parents or a common ancestor with the Clarendon family.
Perinton: matching names in an official archival index
Status: archive index inspected; underlying tax rolls not inspected. Ontario County Records and Archives’ index to former-town tax assessment rolls lists the following on PDF page 26:
| Indexed name | Year | Original roll page | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| George Wescott | 1818 | 19 | Resident |
| Phebe Wescott | 1818 | 19 | Resident |
| George Westcott | 1819 | 17 | Resident |
This is a separate archival lead consistent with David Wescott Smith’s supplied Lewis extracts, which place George Washington Wescott and Olive Waterman’s first two children in “Perrinton” in 1819 and 1820. It does not by itself identify the indexed George as Olive’s husband or the indexed Phebe as his mother, Phebe Salisbury. Those are hypotheses to test. The index is alphabetically arranged: consecutive names, even with the same page reference, do not prove a shared household or adjoining property.
Next check: obtain the 1818 roll, p. 19, and the 1819 roll, p. 17; compare property descriptions, assessments, deeds and other identifying details. An index entry establishes what the index reports, not a parent–child relationship. Ontario County Perinton tax index, p. 26; county tax-index collection. Accessed November 17, 2026.
Samuel: a more specific newspaper trail
Status: searchable text located; newspaper page images not inspected. Direct retrieval of the newspaper PDFs was blocked. The summaries below describe the indexed text, which may contain OCR errors. They are retrieval leads, not completed image transcriptions. Contemporary reporting can also repeat family recollections or another newspaper; agreement does not necessarily mean independent testimony.
March 1, 1902: the centenary account
The indexed text of “Samuel Wescott a Centenarian” reports his hundredth birthday on February 12 at Toledo, Iowa. It gives his birthplace as “Courtland on the Hudson,” Westchester County, New York, on February 12, 1802; says he moved with his parents to western New York; places him in Farmington, Wisconsin, from 1846 to 1870, followed by Gladbrook and Toledo; and explicitly identifies Willett R. Wescott as a son still in Farmington. It does not name Samuel’s parents. This supports a targeted Westchester-origin investigation and the compiled Samuel–Willett relationship, subject to image verification. “Courtland” is retained as the searchable text renders it; it is not silently normalized into a proven birthplace. Kewaskum Statesman, March 1, 1902, “Samuel Wescott a Centenarian” (printed page number not verified).
November 19, 1904: the death notice
The indexed notice reports Samuel’s death at Toledo on November 9, aged 102, identifies him as W. R. Wescott’s father, and calls him a former longtime Farmington resident. This is consistent with the centenary account and family compilation, but does not identify Ananias or Samuel’s mother. Kewaskum Statesman, November 19, 1904 (page image and printed page number not verified).
September 15, 1900: a family gathering
Searchable text lists W. R. Wescott, Bruce Wescott, Cuddeback relatives and Samuel, aged 98, among a family gathering. Its collective description of kinship is not a precise pedigree. This may help identify the family network, but it cannot establish every relationship among the guests. Kewaskum Statesman, September 15, 1900 (page image and printed page number not verified).
A necrology transcription adds a place-name discrepancy
Status: derivative transcription inspected; cited printed original not inspected. Genealogy Trails transcribes a Samuel Westcott entry attributed to Mary Stuart Foster’s “Wisconsin Necrology, 1904–05,” in the Proceedings of the State Historical Society of Wisconsin, fifty-third annual meeting, November 9, 1905 (published 1906), p. 142. It gives Croton on the Hudson, Westchester County, February 12, 1802; arrival in Wisconsin in 1846; and death at Toledo on November 9, 1904. The “Croton” versus “Courtland” wording needs comparison with both originals. Neither account establishes a particular Ananias as Samuel’s father. Wisconsin obituary transcriptions, Samuel Westcott entry.
Assessment: the Samuel–Willett trail has additional contemporary-source leads, while Samuel’s parentage remains unresolved. A Westchester birthplace does not establish that the Bedford Ananias candidate is his father, nor that this candidate is the Ananias associated with Pompey/Nichols. The Samuel–Deborah and Samuel–Bethiah households must remain separate. Earlier household and lineage assessment.
The December 1942 source is a separate genealogical bulletin
Status: Quarterly text and archive description inspected; cited genealogical bulletin and original Bible not inspected. David’s Lewis extract refers to a December 1942 genealogical bulletin concerning a revised child list based on Ziba Westcott’s Bible. The December 1942 Westcott Family Quarterly, vol. IX, no. 35, is a different publication. Its three-page text does not supply that Bible account; page 3 mentions separate genealogical bulletins distributed to libraries.
The society’s description of Roscoe Leighton Whitman’s archive identifies his own bulletin file covering March 1940–March 1949. That is a concrete place to seek the December 1942 item. A historical accession notice in the Pennsylvania Genealogical Magazine, vol. 15, nos. 2–3, printed p. 186, item 48, also records receipt of bulletins from March 1942 through November 1946; this is evidence of historical receipt, not confirmation of present availability.
December 1942 Quarterly, p. 3; SSWDA description of Whitman’s archive; Pennsylvania Genealogical Magazine accession notice, p. 186. These establish a retrieval route; they do not verify the Bible’s contents.
What would move the relationship question forward
- Samuel’s parentage: an original birth, baptism, probate, deed or comparable record identifying Samuel, husband of Bethiah Cuddeback, as a child of named parents. Search Westchester origins and later western New York records without merging same-name households.
- Perinton identity: inspect the 1818 and 1819 tax-roll pages and connect their entries to George–Olive and Phebe through identifying records.
- Clarendon marriage: retrieve book 2, p. 35, for the September 9, 1784 marriage cited in Lewis. The town clerk describes genealogy records extending into the 1700s. Clarendon records information.
- Pension and Bible evidence: obtain the file cited by Lewis as W6455, Rhode Island line, bounty-land reference 18208-160-55, and the December 1942 genealogical bulletin. The specific pension file has not been independently retrieved or its identity confirmed here. NARA identifies the relevant pension series as M804, Record Group 15. National Archives research guide.
No common ancestor or cousin degree is established. These findings narrow the search and strengthen individual research leads; they do not close the gap between the Clarendon–Chautauqua family and Lloyd and Glenway Wescott.