Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026
Perinton Census and Waterman Connection
An official Perinton tax index lists George and Phebe Wescott in 1818. Newspaper text supplies a Samuel–Willett lead and a Westchester birthplace to investigate; the page images still need checking. The separate 1942 genealogical bulletin has been located as an archival target. No connection between the branches is proved. Read the evidence, access limits and next checks →
Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.
Perinton census: probable identification of Coral’s George and Olive household
Editor’s follow-up — 13 November 2026
RESULT
The original 1820 census has now been retrieved and visually inspected. George Wescott’s household on Perinton page 344 is a probable match for George Washington Wescott and Olive Waterman in Coral’s chapter 14. The conclusion rests on the household pattern, timing, locality, and adjacent Waterman entries together. The census names only George, not his wife or children; a deed or other record naming Olive is still needed to strengthen the identification.
THE ORIGINAL RECORD
United States census, 1820, Perinton, Ontario County, New York, p. 344, numbered entry 49; NARA M33, roll 62. FamilySearch DGS 005157009, image 183 of 205 (item 26, image 1 of 3), indexed person XHLB-FD4. Downloaded JPG includes pp. 344–345. The relevant page itself is headed Perinton.
Image: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33S7-9YYG-PXM
Index: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XHLB-FD4
Reading George’s row in the standard 1820 column order:
• One free white male aged 26 and under 45.
• Two free white females under 10.
• One free white female aged 16 and under 26.
• One person engaged in agriculture.
The other free-white age cells in this row are blank. The page lacks repeated column headings; the interpretation uses the National Archives’ published column order and is consistent with the George-household transcription in The Waterman Family (1939), p. 423. The full first-page headings for this enumerator were not located. Census day was 7 August 1820.
Column reference: https://www.archives.gov/research/census/1820
COMPARISON WITH CORAL’S FAMILY
George’s reported birth on 27 February 1793 makes him 27; Olive’s reported birth on 27 November 1800 makes her 19. Coral reports daughters Laura in 1819 and Dianna in 1820. Those facts fit the four-person household, provided Dianna had been born by census day. The exact birth day for Dianna has not been independently established here. This is a fit, not the naming of the three other people in the census.
The two preceding entries are numbered 47 (Calvin Waterman Jr.) and 48 (Calvin Waterman). These are adjacent census entries; they are not proof of adjoining parcels or family relationships. The Waterman genealogy identifies Olive as a daughter of Calvin and Olive (Bates) Waterman and reproduces these three Perinton households together. The original census confirms that the published grouping has a documentary basis. The book’s census transcription and the census image are the same underlying evidence, not two independent witnesses.
WHAT THIS DOES TO “PENNINGTON”
The probable household identification makes Perinton a stronger candidate for the place called “Pennington” in the reading edition of Coral’s account. Do not alter her wording yet. Comparison with the original manuscript/scan remains necessary, and a deed or other named-family record would better establish the migration. The 1818/1819 tax-index names remain candidate matches; this census does not independently identify the indexed Phebe. No older woman appears in George’s four-person household.
A SOURCE TRAIL FOR FAMILY MEMORY
The already-preserved 1939 Waterman genealogy, printed p. 423, contains a footnote worth following. It attributes a family account to a letter from Mrs. George W. Wescott of Sumner, Iowa, to Roscoe L. Whitman of Westfield, New Jersey, historian of the Stukely Westcott genealogy. A copy then passed to Pauline (Wescott) Waterman and through Arnold Root Waterman to the compiler. Page 424 also cites Mrs. George Wescott of Sumner, Iowa, in 1938, and original Cummington vital records, pp. 244, 245 and 254.
This documents a channel through which family recollections entered published genealogy. It does not establish that Coral read this letter, knew its author, or copied this book. The letter itself has not been retrieved, its writer’s personal identity has not been established here, and the 1938 reference should not automatically be assigned to the earlier letter.
MUSIC ON OLIVE’S SIDE
The letter-derived account describes Calvin as a millwright and a musician who taught vocal and instrumental music. It offers relevant context for the musical history within Coral’s own Waterman/Wescott line, rather than relying only on musical parallels with the Hunterdon branch. It remains attributed family testimony. It does not establish who owned, made, played or transmitted Eugene’s fiddle, or demonstrate an inherited musical ability. The same passage claims French ancestry, which the compiler expressly says was not known; do not promote that tradition into fact.
Source: The Waterman Family, volume I (1939), pp. 422–424, especially p. 423 and its footnote.
https://www.cga.ct.gov/hco/books/Descendants_of_Robert_Waterman_1939.pdf
SOURCE CAUTIONS
The Waterman volume gives Olive a death date of 19 March 1886 on p. 424; Coral gives 14 April 1870. The disagreement remains unresolved here. The book also places Perinton in Wayne County in a bracketed note; current town sources place it in Monroe County. Do not let that statement redirect all later research to Wayne County. Palmyra is a separately named locality in the letter-derived account. Record jurisdictions and dates must be checked individually.
LAND AND TAX SEARCH STATUS
The official county tax-index PDF opened in Chrome, but the download stalled; its relevant page 26 was not visually inspected and no original assessment roll was obtained. The earlier indexed tax references remain 1818 p. 19 (George and Phebe), and 1819 p. 17 (George).
The county’s 1789–1845 grantee-index text was searched and the Waterman, Wescott and Westcott sections reviewed. No matching George, Phebe or Calvin acquisition was identified in those sections. A four-page State of Connecticut land-transaction index was also reviewed without identifying them. These bounded index checks do not establish that the families owned no land. Variant indexing, leases, unrecorded transactions and jurisdiction changes remain possible. No new deed naming Olive or Phebe was retrieved.
County deed index: https://www.ontariocountyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/17505/LAND-RECORDS_GRANTEE_DEED_INDEX_1789-1845
Connecticut index: https://www.ontariocountyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/6900
EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT
This is meaningful corroboration of the setting of Coral’s account: a likely young George/Olive family at Perinton, with the expected two young daughters, in the same census sequence as Olive’s reported father and brother. It is stronger than the previous name-only index lead. It does not establish a relationship to Ananias, Samuel/Bethiah, or the Hunterdon family.
PRESERVED IMAGES
records/perinton-census-1820-p344-345.jpg: full downloaded census image, original public record held by NARA, digital image supplied by FamilySearch.
images/perinton-waterman-wescott-1820.png: unretouched crop of entries 47–49 and portions of neighboring rows, with no added names or reconstructed handwriting.
records/waterman-428.png and waterman-429.png: previously preserved page images of printed pp. 423–424, now re-examined for census and correspondence context.