Family & Belonging · 4 min read
A County Without a Hospital
In 1946, Hunterdon County had an embarrassment that was also a daily problem: it was the only county in New Jersey without a comprehensive hospital.
Samuel Gorton’s occupation should have supplied a straightforward description. He was a clothier, a man engaged in the finishing of cloth.
Yet in a London document discussed by his later biographer, another description accompanies the trade: “Professor of the misteries of Christ.” Here, professor meant someone who professed a faith. Gorton could be identified by the work he did and by the religious convictions he declared. The second would make it difficult for him to keep a home in New England.
He crossed the Atlantic seeking liberty of conscience. By the time he settled at Plymouth, that hope had become a practical question: how much disagreement would a community permit before it required the dissenter to leave?
One dispute began with a servant in his household. According to the historical accounts, Gorton believed she had been treated unjustly and spoke in her defense. His challenge widened into criticism of the magistrates themselves. In December 1638, Plymouth banished him.
He moved to Rhode Island. Further conflict followed at Portsmouth, where accounts describe imprisonment, whipping and another expulsion. The sequence makes a harsh itinerary: establish a household, challenge authority, leave. His beliefs traveled with him. So did his willingness to argue.
The remembered family version gives those beliefs a striking simplicity: God was within people, so they needed neither ministers nor laws.
There is something recognizable in that account. Gorton rejected a paid ministry and the claim that outward religious observances could govern the spiritual life. His followers understood faith in terms that challenged the distinctions enforced by established churches. A minister’s position did not, for Gorton, settle the question of religious truth.
But the part about laws needs more care. Gorton appealed to English legal authority and disputed the right of particular colonial governments to exercise power over him. The man who resisted magistrates would later serve in government himself. His quarrel concerned the grounds and limits of authority, including its reach into conscience. Describing him simply as an enemy of all law loses the argument he spent so much of his life making.
At Shawomet, the settlement that became Warwick, the disputes grew more dangerous. Land claims and colonial jurisdiction became entangled with the religious accusations against him. Massachusetts authorities imprisoned Gorton in 1643. The question of where he and his companions could live had become inseparable from the question of what they could teach.
Gorton answered in print. His 1646 account bore the title Simplicities Defence against Seven-Headed Policy. Even before the reader reaches its argument, the title reveals a man presenting himself and his companions as the injured party. It is evidence from inside the struggle, written by someone determined that the authorities should not have the only surviving version.
Eventually he remained at Warwick. He held town and colonial offices and served as president of the mainland towns in 1651–1652. The repeated expulsions did not prevent him from becoming part of the government of the place where he settled.
His place in this family’s history comes through his daughter Ann. Published genealogies identify her as the wife of John Warner and their daughter Mary as the wife of Jeremiah Westcott Jr., Stukely Westcott’s grandson. In that marriage, the families of two early Rhode Island settlers came together.
The relationship survives in more than a modern family-tree label. Roscoe Whitman’s Westcott genealogy identifies Mary’s parents and transcribes a receipt from 1712 in which Jeremiah acknowledges property received from his father-in-law, John Warner. Betty Acker’s later lineage for Devere Wescott places Jeremiah and Mary in the succession leading to George Washington Wescott, Olive Waterman and Orris Waterman Wescott. These are published genealogical accounts, with original records still to be examined, but they give Gorton a supported place in the Wescott ancestry.
Across those generations the surname changed. Gorton became part of the family through Ann, then Mary, whose children carried the Westcott name. A search confined to the surname at the end of the line could pass him by.
Gorton’s followers did not leave behind a large religious institution bearing his name. A National Park Service historical study notes that the Gortonists never established a formal church. His surviving record lies instead in writings, disputes and the history of the community where he finally stayed.
The clothier had crossed an ocean for freedom of conscience. Several towns made him move again before he found a place where his household—and his disagreements—could remain.
This literary nonfiction account uses published historical and genealogical sources. The Gorton descent runs through Ann Gorton and Mary Warner, wife of Jeremiah Westcott Jr. Original records underlying the compiled lineage remain to be inspected. Sources vary between Mary Warner, Mary Gorton Warner and the family database’s Mary Ann Warner; uncertain dates are omitted.
Lewis G. Janes: Samuell Gorton (1896) — https://www.gutenberg.org/files/52573/52573-h/52573-h.htm
Religious-history reference: Gorton — https://www.ccel.org/s/schaff/encyc05/htm/iii.iv.xlv.htm
Rhode Island Heritage Hall of Fame: Samuel Gorton — https://riheritagehalloffame.com/samuel-gorton/
Columbia Encyclopedia: Gorton — https://www.encyclopedia.com/reference/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/gorton-samuel
NPS historical study: Flushing Remonstrance — https://parkplanning.nps.gov/showFile.cfm?projectID=67770&sfid=336329
Whitman: Westcott genealogy, printed p. 155 — https://www.seekingmyroots.com/members/files/G006977.pdf
Westcott Society: Betty Acker’s Devere Wescott lineage — https://sswda.org/Old-sswda-org/old/Archives/Items/calendar.htm
Gorton family compilation: Ann and Mary Warner — https://www.gottschfamily.net/Gorton/5.html
Keep reading