Friendships & FeudsBusiness & AmbitionRemarkable Characters

The Sixpence Tavern

James Calhoun had a cabin, a three-gallon keg of whiskey and sixpence. In early East Fallowfield Township, Pennsylvania, this was apparently enough to attempt a tavern business, provided the proprietor did not insist on very much working capital. The tale survives in a county history published in 1885, long enough after the event for its more comic features to have been polished by retelling. Yet the essential arrangements are wonderfully simple. Calhoun obtained two measures from a tinner in Meadville, filled the keg at Thomas Frame's distillery, appointed his wife bartender and decided the new establishment would operate strictly for cash.

The first customer in the telling was also the proprietor. Calhoun gave his wife the sixpence for a drink. She now had the house's entire cash reserve. Evidently unwilling to let her husband enjoy the new establishment alone, she purchased a drink from him with the same coin, which came back across the counter into his possession. Husband and wife continued trading places as customer and vendor, each transaction restoring the sixpence to its starting role in the next. The little business could boast of payment for every drink, although its cash position never improved beyond the original coin.

The county historian reports that the arrangement lasted until the three-gallon keg was emptied, after which tavern-keeping was abandoned. It is a nearly perfect account of money changing hands without accumulating, but it also belongs to a place where enterprise was improvised from whatever people owned and knew how to use. A cabin could double as a place of trade. Someone operating a distillery supplied whiskey. A tinner furnished measures. The business was domestic enough that the bartender and the customers lived under the same roof, and brief enough that its entire stock could be consumed before the novelty wore off.

Whether the episode occurred exactly as the historian tells it is another matter. There is no surviving tavern ledger in the material reviewed, and the written account was compiled generations afterward. The two measures, the keg, the coin and the exchange may be faithful to a remembered event, or the pattern may have gained symmetry as neighbors enjoyed repeating it. We should identify it as a local anecdote rather than an audited statement of nineteenth-century sales. The humor belongs to the telling, and the telling itself is part of the township's social history.

Thomas Frame provides a connection with another, more consequential undertaking. He had contracted for four hundred acres in 1797 and operated a still alongside his farming. Frame's role here was simply to supply the whiskey, according to the local account. It brings him out of the land-contract tables and into the small commerce of a settlement where neighbors traded goods and services long before every occupation had a separate storefront. Calhoun himself also appears in the land history, having settled on part of a tract in the township. The pioneer economy contained both substantial land dealings and brief experiments that left behind little but a joke.

The account of Calhoun's later life is darker. The same history says he died at Erie after a third amputation of his arms following accidental poisoning. The circumstances are too spare for a confident medical narrative, but the statement is a sharp reminder that the cheerful tavern story did not encompass the whole man's life. He was not merely a comic figure devised to demonstrate the limits of cash trade. He worked, settled and suffered in a world that could be cruel as well as absurd.

There are many ways to spend sixpence. Calhoun and his wife managed to pass the same coin from hand to hand until their whiskey was gone, and the county historian remembered them for it. Whatever the tavern earned in real money, it enjoyed a remarkably durable second life as a story.

Behind the Story · sources and review notes

Form: Literary retelling of a local anecdote, attributed to a later source. Source: History of Crawford County (1885), East Fallowfield Township: https://crawfordcopa.com/history/1885/efallowfield. Boundaries: No direct record of the accounts, dialogue or precise date survives in the reviewed material. The later description of Calhoun's death is presented without invented medical details. Connections: Thomas Frame's distillery, East Fallowfield enterprise; no assumed genealogical kinship. Contribute: Contemporary township or Calhoun family accounts are welcome for review.