Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026

Coral Research Impact and Perinton

Editor’s note · 13 November 2026

Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.

Editor’s follow-up: original Perinton census retrieved. George’s four-person household fits the reported ages of George and Olive and their two young daughters, and follows Calvin Waterman Jr. and Calvin Waterman. Identification is probable, not proved by names of wife and children. The Waterman genealogy also preserves a letter-derived account of Calvin teaching music, with no demonstrated fiddle provenance or Hunterdon connection. Read the original-image assessment and correspondence lead.
Research overview

What the research changes for Coral’s family history
Editor’s research note — 13 November 2026

A NEW LEAD ON CORAL’S OWN FAMILY: PERINTON, 1818–1820
Coral’s chapter 14 says George Wescott and Olive Waterman married in 1818, first lived at “Pennington,” and had daughters Laura (1819) and Dianna (1820) before moving to Hamburg. She also describes the older Phebe Salisbury Wescott’s movement from Vermont into New York.

Ontario County Records and Archives’ tax-assessment index for Perinton lists:
• George Wescott — 1818, original roll page 19, Resident.
• Phebe Wescott — 1818, original roll page 19, Resident.
• George Westcott — 1819, original roll page 17, Resident.
The entries appear on index page 26. They were available in the search engine’s indexed text of the official county PDF. Direct retrieval of that tax-index PDF returned HTTP 403; neither its page image nor the original rolls were inspected. These are promising index leads, not a completed identification.
Source: https://www.ontariocountyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/43437/INDEX_TaxAssessmentRolls_FormerTowns_1799-1822---Perinton

A second county index, for the 1820 census, lists George Wescott in Perinton, census page 344. This PDF was opened and its text checked (PDF page 165 of 174). The original census household has not yet been examined.
Source: https://www.ontariocountyny.gov/DocumentCenter/View/769/Census_Ontario-County_New-York_1820?bidId=

EDITOR’S INTERPRETATION
The dates and paired names make Perinton a worthwhile locality to test against Coral’s account. Perinton might explain “Pennington,” but this remains a hypothesis. The index does not identify George’s wife or Phebe’s maiden name, and shared roll-page numbers do not prove kinship, co-residence, or neighboring properties. An alphabetically arranged roll or index can place unrelated people together. Do not silently change Coral’s text or treat these names as identified ancestors.

WHY THIS COULD MATTER
If the original records identify the younger George and his mother Phebe, they would place members of Coral’s family at a specific intermediate stop before Hamburg and Harmony. Phebe’s separate resident assessment would also supply a record of her in her own name. The assessment’s contents, not the index alone, must establish the nature and value of any property. No connection to Samuel, Ananias or the Cuddebacks follows from these entries.

THE MOST DIRECT NEXT CHECKS
1. Perinton original assessment rolls: 1818 p. 19 and 1819 p. 17. Transcribe names, land descriptions, acreage, valuations and any qualifying labels; compare the same property across years.
2. Original 1820 Perinton census, p. 344: inspect household age categories and compare them with George, Olive, their young daughters and possible other household members. The schedule cannot name every household member, and a matching age pattern alone will not prove identity.
3. Deeds for the indexed Perinton property: look for George’s wife Olive and for Phebe, and follow residence descriptions, prior owners and later purchasers. Those details could distinguish this family from namesakes and locate its next move.
4. Compare Coral’s original manuscript/scan with the reading edition’s word “Pennington” before attributing the difference to Coral rather than transcription.

WHAT THE BROADER INVESTIGATION HAS ACCOMPLISHED
The Hunterdon material gives a specific Ananias parentage claim to test, replacing an unsupported Stephen-based route as the main lead. The deeds distinguish Samuel/Deborah’s earlier 94-acre holding from Samuel/Bethiah’s later smaller parcels. An 1843 deed places Ananias and Dameras in Nichols. Graudis’s administration identifies widow Jane and coadministrator Joshua; the estate-share deeds supply a concrete basis for testing Bethiah’s parentage. The Cardiff history supplies a church association and an unnamed-wife/De Witt niece lead. These results substantially improve identification and research direction within that branch, but none establishes its relationship to Coral.

Coral’s own text preserves everyday family experiences—Olive’s textile work, settlement in Hamburg and Harmony, and the care given to elderly Phebe—that the new Hunterdon evidence neither verifies nor discredits. They should remain attributed family narrative. The direct Perinton lead now gives an opportunity to test one geographic detail of that narrative in records.

CURRENT CONCLUSION
There has been an impact on our understanding: we can separate the households more accurately, identify what the family compilations actually assert, and pursue a specific new locality for Coral’s ancestors. We have not established the desired common ancestor. The next emphasis should be on George, Phebe and Olive’s own records while retaining the Ananias/Cuddeback file as a separate investigation.

SEARCH LIMITS
Additional public-web searches did not identify Cuddeback’s unnamed wife as a particular De Witt niece, obtain Phebe’s pension, or prove the Perinton identities. Absence from these searches is not evidence that those records do not exist.