Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026

Probate and Parentage

Editor’s note · 13 November 2026

Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.

Editor’s research follow-up · 13 November 2026

Correction after further record review — 13 November 2026. The 1819 mortgage names Samuel’s wife as Deborah, and Samuel and Deborah sell the 94-acre lot 72 tract to John Haynes in 1836. Keep that household separate from Samuel and Bethiah. The acquisition of Bethiah’s husband’s smaller lot 72 parcels remains untraced. A September 1843 deed places Ananias and Dameras in Nichols, Tioga County. No probate for this couple or bridge to Coral has been identified. Read the current assessment and new record images.
Assessment: Ananias as the father of Samuel (1802–1904) has stronger published support than the 2002 compilation alone. Original land-record images also connect an Ananias and Samuel in Pompey, Onondaga County. The later follow-up above identifies a wife conflict: the early Samuel was married to Deborah. These land records cannot presently be treated as converging proof for Bethiah’s husband.

This follow-up uses the FamilySearch access authorized after sign-in. Nine downloaded record-image PDFs are preserved with their supplied citations and machine transcripts. Key names, dates and clauses discussed below were checked against the images. The transcripts themselves remain uncorrected and can contain errors. Typed county record copies are distinguished from original signed instruments; a copied signature is not an autograph.

The strongest new lead: a traceable property in Pompey

RecordWhat it documentsWhat it does not establish
6 July 1819; recorded 26 July 1819Jacob Ryder and Margaret his wife conveyed 94 acres in lot 72, Pompey, to Ananias Wescott and Samuel Wescott, both of Pompey, for $658. Boundaries begin at a marked hemlock on William Sniffin’s south line, and mention Abraham Newton’s land. Page 577 and page 578.No ages or relationship are given. If the buyer is Samuel born 12 February 1802, he was 17. That is an identity question to resolve, not a reason to silently merge names.
9 June 1821; acknowledged 3 April 1833; recorded 8 June 1833Ananias Wescott and Damaris his wife conveyed the described 94-acre tract in lot 72 to Samuel Wescott, all of Pompey, for $120. The starting point and surrounding land match the earlier purchase. Page 332.The deed does not call Samuel their son. A transfer by co-owners can have several explanations. Damaris is documented as Ananias’s wife in this transaction, not yet as Samuel’s mother.
24 March 1842; recorded 18 June 1842Samuel Wescott and Bethiah his wife, of La Fayette, conveyed parcels in lot 72 of the original town of Pompey, now La Fayette, to Robert Haynes for $650. One parcel begins at the same marked hemlock on Sniffin’s south line and repeats the initial boundary courses; the deed describes 17 acres and four rods, plus another five acres. Pages 176–177.This is strong evidence connecting the land trail to a Samuel married to Bethiah. It does not state his birth, parents, or later Wisconsin/Iowa residence. A complete chain of title and household comparison are still needed.

Editor’s interpretation: matching names, location, lot number, starting point, neighboring Sniffin property and boundary courses make this substantially more informative than a surname match. The 1819 and 1821 instruments concern the same described 94-acre tract; the 1842 transaction concerns smaller parcels within lot 72 with a matching starting boundary. The newly retrieved mortgage and 1836 deed identify the early Samuel with Deborah. The property trail remains useful, but a transfer connecting that household to Samuel–Bethiah has not been found. It is not proof of parentage.

Transcription correction: the 1821 deed’s acknowledgment reads 1833 on the image, although the automated text misreads it as 1823. Execution, acknowledgment and recording are different dates. The image reads lot seventy two. Retain all three dates in future citations.

A 1910 biography explicitly names Ananias

J. R. Caldwell, compiler and editor, A History of Tama County, Iowa, volume II (Chicago/New York: Lewis Publishing Company, 1910), page 776, describes Graudis C. Wescott as a son of Samuel, born in Westchester County on 12 February 1802, and a grandson of Ananias Wescott. It says Ananias came from the New England states to Westchester County. Samuel subsequently lived in Onondaga County, Wisconsin and Iowa. Read the page and facing portrait; bibliographic identification.

This is explicit published evidence of the relationship and predates the 2002 family book by 92 years. It is still a retrospective biography with an unidentified informant. The 2002 compilation may draw on this account, so the two publications must not be counted automatically as independent testimony. The biography calls Samuel’s wife “Mattie Cuddeback,” gives their marriage as 1826 in Onondaga County, and gives the Wisconsin move as 1847. Those details conflict with Bethiah, the reported Tioga marriage location, and the 1846 migration date elsewhere. The 1842 deed independently documents a wife named Bethiah.

What the retrieved probate record actually proves

Abraham Westcott of Cantito, Bedford: the recorded copy of his will dated 24 January 1786 names son Ananias as a principal beneficiary and executor, wife Elizabeth, daughter Elinor, sons Justice, Caleb, Abraham and Thomas, daughters Sarah Randell, Susanna Brown and Ruth Weldon, and a grandson Samuel. The probate and executor’s oath are dated 29 September 1791. Pages 304–305; page 306 and following unrelated will.

Documented: this Abraham had a son Ananias and a grandson Samuel. Not documented: which of Abraham’s children was the parent of that grandson. The Samuel named in a 1786 will proved in 1791 cannot be the Samuel born in 1802. This record therefore cannot supply the proposed Abraham → Ananias → Samuel (1802) chain.

The typed probate testimony on page 306 gives the will date as January 1796, inconsistent with the 1786 date in the will and the 1791 probate and oath. This is a discrepancy in the imaged copy, not merely an OCR error. An earlier manuscript or original probate packet should resolve it. It does not make the named grandson a person born in 1802.

Ananias’s own will has not been retrieved. A Bedford deed dated 15 May 1834 explicitly refers to a will of Ananias Wescott, late of Bedford, dated 20 February 1824. That gives a concrete target for obtaining the actual will. The deed concerns ten acres of the Forguson lot, with neighboring land devised to Abigail. Opening on page 277; pages 278–279. The downloaded excerpt does not include the following recording endorsement.

The grantors include Stephen and Betsey Wescott, Huey and Deborah Wescott, Abigail Wescott, and Smith and Sally Wescott. Other named parties include the Knapp, Todd, Bostwick, Rowland, Ferris and Dann families. These are useful people to trace through the estate; the deed alone does not establish that every party is a child of Ananias. Samuel is not named in this transaction, which is not proof that he was not a child.

Keep the candidate households separate

CandidateEvidence and current treatment
Bedford Ananias; Hannah connectionThe 28 March 1780 marriage of Ananias Westcoat and Hannah Clark is in the Salem, Westchester church material printed in The New York Genealogical and Biographical Record 31 (1900), p. 177. Printed source image. Do not relocate this marriage to Washington County from a modern index. The previously found 1750–1833 Bedford candidate and this couple need their own identity analysis.
Pompey Ananias; Damaris connectionThe 1819 and 1821 deeds place Ananias with Samuel in Onondaga County. The 1821 instrument calls Damaris his wife. Further review identifies the early Samuel’s wife as Deborah; a direct connection to Samuel–Bethiah remains unproved.
Same man or different men?Unresolved. Different places and wives are reasons to keep separate research identities, not sufficient proof of two men. No retrieved document establishes a move from Bedford to Pompey or a Hannah-to-Damaris marriage sequence. Do not assign the Bedford birth, death, parents or children to the Pompey man.

Does this connect to Coral?

No documented bridge has yet emerged. The new material advances the Hunterdon branch’s earlier generations but does not identify an ancestor shared with Coral. The existing Coral narrative runs through George and Phebe Salisbury Wescott → George Washington Wescott and Olive Waterman → Orris Waterman Wescott → Eugene Merritt Wescott. Those later links have not all been re-proved in this follow-up.

On the Coral side, Donald Lines Jacobus, The Waterman Family, volume I, compiled under Edgar Francis Waterman (1939), p. 424, identifies Olive Waterman’s 1818 husband George Washington Wescott as born at Clarendon, Vermont, 27 February 1793, son of George and Phebe (Salisbury) Wescott. Page 424 image; complete digitized volume. This supports the Coral-side couple, without connecting George to Ananias.

The preceding page’s note traces family information through Mrs. George W. Wescott of Sumner, Iowa, Roscoe L. Whitman, Pauline (Wescott) Waterman and Arnold Root Waterman. Page 423 image. Those named correspondents and cited Cummington vital-record pages are specific research leads. They also warn against treating later genealogies repeating that information as independent evidence. The book’s preface describes an intended deposit of underlying material with the Connecticut Historical Society; present holdings were not verified.

Research priorities changed by these findings

  1. Resolve the Pompey household first. Search Ananias and Damaris together in Onondaga probate, deeds, mortgages, tax lists, censuses, church and burial records. Determine when each died and look for estate distributions, heirs’ conveyances or guardianships identifying Samuel. Damaris’s surname remains unknown.
  2. Complete the lot 72 title chain. Follow the 1819 purchase, 1821 conveyance, its delayed 1833 recording, and Samuel–Bethiah’s 1842 sale through the remaining 1830s–1840s instruments. Test whether the later household moved to Washington County, Wisconsin. Resolve whether the 1819 buyer was the 17-year-old Samuel or another man. Matching property is strong identity evidence, but ages and household continuity must also fit.
  3. Obtain the actual Bedford will dated 20 February 1824. The 1834 deed proves a will with that stated date was invoked, but not its complete contents. Check the original county file and all relevant will/proof volumes; the limited volume-index review in this session is not an exhaustive negative search.
  4. Use the exact collateral probate references already found. Eleanor Wescott, Bedford, 1817: will A-0365(19)L, folder 19; estate A-018(14)L_SCAN, folder 28, file 1817-50. Smith Wescott, Lewisboro, 1872: estate A-0255(91)L, folder 7, file 1872-405. Ananias, North Salem, 1886: estate A-0255(314)L, folder 27, file 1886-419; will indexed Westcott, A-0154(9)F, folder 7. These packets were not retrieved in this follow-up and should not be described as read. County probate index.
  5. Then test a bridge to Coral. Trace George Wescott and Phebe Salisbury in Clarendon land, probate and church records; pursue the Waterman correspondence and its cited original records. Only compare ancestry after the two earliest households are securely identified. Shared surname, New England origin, and published family tradition cannot establish a cousin degree.

Scope and source register

Downloaded: Abraham’s recorded will and probate, two images of the 1834 Bedford deed, the 1819 joint purchase and continuation, the 1821 Ananias–Damaris deed, the 1842 Samuel–Bethiah deed, and the 1910 Graudis biography/portrait. The original signed wills/deeds were not obtained. A related 1826 deed mentioning Samuel and Ananias as neighboring landholders was read in automated transcript only and is not used as image-verified proof here. Search results and unchecked transcripts are leads, not conclusions.

FamilySearch full-text searches included Wescott/Westcott, Ananias, Westchester probate-related terms, and Samuel Wescott in Onondaga. Limited inspection of 1832–1835 will-volume indexes did not locate the Bedford Ananias will. This is a bounded search, not evidence that no will or estate survives. Public 1924 NYG&B will abstracts reviewed did not supply the required parentage.

See the source register (retained in the private research package) for stable image links, digital group numbers, file hashes, page references and limitations. All source access was on 13 November 2026. The older online report remains as a dated research trail; this follow-up supersedes its candidate ranking and access limitations. Changes are local editorial additions, with no live website publication.