Editor’s research additions · 13 November 2026

Online Research

Editor’s note · 13 November 2026

Dated research log; some findings superseded. This preserves the search trail, including earlier hypotheses. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. In particular, the early lot 72 Samuel was Deborah’s husband, Graudis’s administration has since been retrieved, and no bridge to Coral has been established. Read the current conclusions and corrections first. FamilySearch may require sign-in. Source scans and family image extracts remain in the private research package.

New: retrieved probate and land records. Read the latest assessment of Ananias, Samuel, Damaris, Bethiah and Coral’s line, with nine downloaded record-image PDFs and a newly extracted Graudis portrait. This follow-up supersedes the earlier report’s access limitations and candidate ranking.

Additional online research · 13 November 2026

Correction after further record review — 13 November 2026. The 1819 mortgage names Samuel’s wife as Deborah, and Samuel and Deborah sell the 94-acre lot 72 tract to John Haynes in 1836. Keep that household separate from Samuel and Bethiah. The acquisition of Bethiah’s husband’s smaller lot 72 parcels remains untraced. A September 1843 deed places Ananias and Dameras in Nichols, Tioga County. No probate for this couple or bridge to Coral has been identified. Read the current assessment and new record images.

Yes: the society pages create a specific new research path through Ananias Wescott, Westchester County, and the family’s New York–Wisconsin migration. They still do not prove a common ancestor between Coral’s family and the Hunterdon Wescotts. This report separates records located, compiled assertions, and hypotheses. Online access and indexes are not equivalent to inspecting the underlying record.

1. The strongest new lead: Ananias, with competing identities

The supplied compilation names Ananias as Samuel’s father (printed pp. 133, 163), but marks his birth year <1774> as unconfirmed. A Westchester County Historical Society Revolutionary burial index, p. 52, lists an Ananias Wescott, 1750–1833, in Cantitoe Cemetery, Bedford, associated with the 2nd Regiment. That is a geographically plausible candidate, not an identification. The index derives from historical veteran-grave documentation; it is not a birth or parentage record.

Editor’s note OR-01 — Do not merge these men. A 1750 birth and an unconfirmed 1774 birth are materially different. Neither the shared name nor Samuel’s reported Westchester birthplace resolves the conflict. Search both Wescott and Westcott; keep separate candidate profiles until a record links Samuel to one of them.

A transcription of Whitman’s 1932 genealogy places an Ananias born in 1750 in a Bedford family it traces through Richard Westcott. Its listed children do not include Samuel. This raises a testable alternative to the Stukely tradition, but proves neither Samuel’s parentage nor the colonial pedigree. A missing child in a compiled list is not proof that he was not a son. The original genealogy and its sources need checking.

2. Actual probate entries found

I searched the Westchester County Archives Surrogate’s Court index under both spellings. The following are concrete retrieval targets. Only the index entries were inspected; the wills and estate papers themselves were not obtained. No 1833 Ananias entry appeared in these surname results. The site warns that its index is incomplete, so that negative result cannot rule out an estate.

Indexed personRecord referenceQuestion to test
Abraham Wescott, Bedford, 1791Will: A-0365(1)L_SCAN, folder 23Does the will name Ananias, and what relationships does it actually state?
Eleanor Wescott, Bedford, 1817Will: A-0365(19)L, folder 19. Estate: A-018(14)L_SCAN, folder 28; file 1817-50.Are Ananias or Samuel identified among heirs, legatees, guardians or witnesses?
Smith Wescott, Lewisboro, 1872Estate: A-0255(91)L, folder 7; file 1872-405.Can relatives and residences distinguish the Bedford family from Samuel’s line?
Ananias Wescott/Westcott, North Salem, 1886Estate: A-0255(314)L, folder 27; file 1886-419. Will under Westcott: A-0154(9)F, folder 7.Identify this later namesake before connecting him to either older candidate.

The most efficient next step is to obtain these instruments and a full search for the 1833 candidate’s probate or administration, including unindexed material. Ask for heir petitions and distribution papers as well as wills: they may name children who are absent from a testament. No order or message has been sent.

3. Contemporary reporting strengthens the migration trail

The indexed text of the Kewaskum Statesman, 1 March 1902, identifies Samuel as a centenarian born in Westchester County and follows him to Wisconsin and Iowa, with Willett remaining in Farmington. It names the youngest soldier son as Benjamin, conflicting with the supplied genealogy’s Timothy. That discrepancy makes the article useful evidence to compare, not a replacement authority. The PDF image could not be consistently retrieved; this finding rests on indexed text.

The online text of the Kewaskum Statesman, 19 November 1904, reports Samuel’s death on 9 November at Toledo, Iowa, and identifies him as W. R. Wescott’s father. This is an additional contemporary source supporting the Samuel–Willett connection. The newspaper was located in searchable PDF text, but its image was not visually checked because subsequent access failed.

A transcribed Wisconsin Historical Society necrology cites Proceedings (1906), p. 142: Samuel’s birthplace is rendered Croton on the Hudson, Westchester County, his arrival in Wisconsin as 1846, and death at Toledo on 9 November 1904. This supplies a precise original-volume target and an alternative place name to investigate. The original page was not inspected. These notices do not name his parents; their independence from family information remains unknown.

4. Other Ananias and Wisconsin namesakes matter

A Washington County Old Settlers roster transcription lists an Ananias Wescott born 8 January 1832 at Nichols, Tioga County, arriving in 1853. He cannot be father of Samuel born in 1802. He may be a collateral relative worth investigating, but the roster alone supplies no relationship. Nichols adds a useful location for census, church, land and probate searches.

A 12th Wisconsin roster transcription lists George T. Wescott and Garner Wescott separately, alongside several familiar family names. Do not collapse George T., tentatively mentioned in the society genealogy, into George Garner. Shared regiment or company is a way to find associates; it does not demonstrate kinship. Service and pension originals may identify next of kin, addresses and affidavits.

A separate family-history account of Stephen Henry Westcott describes another Wayne County–Wisconsin family, with children including George Garner. This offers an explanation for overlapping places and names in earlier research. It is a secondary lead, not evidence that Stephen fathered Samuel or connected the two histories.

5. Searches with the best chance of resolving parentage

  1. Westchester probate and deeds. Begin with the exact entries above, then look for an Ananias-to-Samuel conveyance, heirs’ sale, guardianship, or estate distribution. A record must explicitly link the individuals and fit their residences and ages.
  2. New York household reconstruction. Track each Ananias separately through Bedford/Westchester and Onondaga/Tioga records. The 1790 Bedford census transcription includes Ananias Westcott, but that census predates Samuel’s birth and names only household heads. It cannot establish the son. Inspect original schedules and follow deeds and tax lists rather than treating adjacency as kinship.
  3. Samuel and Bethiah’s 1826 marriage. Search church and surviving local marriage material around Tioga and their known New York locations, using Cuddeback as well as Wescott/Westcott. A marriage entry, Bible, or family letter may supply a parent or witness whose identity can be checked.
  4. Obtain the compilation’s evidence. Seek the research behind Ananias on pp. 133 and 163, the correspondence behind the Stukely claim on p. 3, and Willett’s handwritten migration account. Those missing sources are more promising than extending an unsupported online tree.
  5. Build Coral’s side independently. Establish George Wescott and Phebe Salisbury’s parents through original records before testing any meeting point with Ananias’s family. Shared surname, music, military service, or migration is insufficient to assign a cousin degree.
Editor’s conclusion: The Hunterdon branch is better documented through Samuel, Willett and Bruce. Ananias is now a named parentage claim to test. A Bedford/Westchester alternative has emerged, together with retrievable probate references. The common ancestor with Coral’s line and any exact cousin relationship remain unresolved.

Bibliographic clarification

The supplied title page lacks a date. The Google Books catalog dates Our Wescott Family Story to 2002 and describes 246 pages. This is catalog metadata, not information printed on the supplied title page.